The certainty of the gut

How does it differ from the certainty in my mind?

-oOo-

This week’s passage used by my shared Lectio Divina group was John 8.21-30. I was struck by the last verse: “As [Jesus] was saying these things, many believed in him.”

In Lectio we hear the passage twice then have 10 minutes to ponder it – not just using our minds, but letting the word or phrase sink into our hearts. According to John, though, many people listening to Jesus (or if not listening precisely at least present as he was teaching) didn’t need a second reading or a moment’s reflection – they believed in Jesus as he was speaking. That is, maybe not so much with their minds, but in their hearts and guts. Maybe in the content of Jesus’ words, or maybe primarily in the way that he was speaking and looked at or through each person.

… which set me thinking about the difference between certainty in my mind and certainty in my gut.

I have a knot of certainty in my gut that God exists, that God is holding on to me, and upholding me. At the same time, in my mind I hold to the truth that uncertainty and doubt are good (even necessary), and fit together intimately with faith, while certainty is the enemy of faith and love. I draw a distinction between the certainty of the mind and the certainty of the gut. The certainty of the gut is the deep knowledge that God has me, and an equally deep unknowing of the nature of God, other than as the One who has me. The certainty of the mind tries to make God in my image. The certainty of the gut knows that the mind will never come close to grasping the reality of God.

-oOo-

I’m also reminded of this excerpt from a letter written by Gerard Manley Hopkins to Robert Bridges (24 October 1883; my emphasis):

You do not mean by mystery what a Catholic does. You mean an interesting uncertainty: the uncertainty ceasing, interest ceases also… But a Catholic by mystery means an incomprehensible certainty: without certainty, without formulation there is no interest;… the clearer the formulation the greater the interest.

I would be with Hopkins.

-oOo-

Lectio Divina, or divine reading, is an ancient and tried-and-tested form of praying with the Bible. Slow reading, chewing it over, offering those reflections to God, and then simply resting in God’s presence. The weekly Lectio group I run is currently working its way through John’s Gospel, and I am aiming here to turn my reflections into the sort of coherent form that might be helpful.

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that I can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to my website and helping me to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

You can adjust all of your cookie settings by navigating the tabs on the left hand side.